Some positions may be slightly better than others, but that's the way the Lead Pipe crumbles. Excellent design. To maintain that creepy sneaking around feeling you really have to leave fog on. Nothing better than attacking someone and finding out you've wiped them out.
A tough board to rate. Excellent graphics work, and balanced about as well as a two person set-scenario board can be balanced. However, starting units and attack options are extremely limited, putting this board way over on the 'luck' side of the strategy <-> luck scale. Very easy to either win or lose the game in the first two turns. Not my cup of tea, but still a good implementation of this type of map.
If I had 1/2 stars it would get a 7.5... Interesting strategy packed into this tiny board. With everything being so 'equal' it plays out sort of like a poker match, in that reading your opponents is vital to success. Groovy board design.
Since this is the basic map a rating on game-play would be pointless, so I'm rating the graphical implementation. If I could do half stars it would get 7.5. It's better than Good, but not quite Great. =]